Intel Comet Lake vs. Ice Lake

0
49


Intel’s last-generation lineup included Comet Lake and Ice Lake processors, with the previous out there on desktop and cellular and the latter completely in laptops. Even with the launch of latest processors on desktop and cellular, there’s nonetheless a cause to stay with considered one of Intel’s last-gen components, and on this Intel Comet Lake versus Ice Lake comparability, we’re going that can assist you select between them.

Each strains fall underneath the Intel Tenth-gen banner, however there are some important variations between them. Comet Lake marks the fourth optimization of Intel’s 14nm course of, whereas Ice Lake chips use Intel’s new 10nm course of. On high of that, each sequence of processors can be found in cellular configurations, however solely Comet Lake chips can be found on desktop. We seemingly received’t see 10nm processors on desktop till 2022.

That can assist you determine between the 2, we’ve rounded up each chip out there in Comet Lake and Ice Lake, and on this information, we’ll evaluate the strains immediately so yow will discover the greatest processor for you.

Availability and pricing

Walden Kirsch/Intel Company

Laptops with 10nm Ice Lake CPUs launched in the summertime of 2019. These embrace Microsoft’s Floor Laptop computer 3, the Razer Blade Stealth, the HP Spectre x360 13, Dell’s XPS 13, and lots of extra. The “U” within the processor label interprets to “ultra-low energy,” that means it targets a superb steadiness of efficiency and battery. The “Y” chips do the identical however usually have decrease base speeds.

Laptops with 14nm Comet Lake “U” and “Y” arrived in the identical timeframe, packing extra core and threads on the increased finish. Intel didn’t launch its “H” sequence chips for laptops till early April 2020, adopted by desktop processors later that month. These latter chips now exchange the complete ninth-gen Espresso Lake vary of desktop CPUs.

Intel isn’t slated to launch a 10nm desktop processor till 2021 and even 2022, so we don’t count on to see Ice Lake on desktops anytime within the subsequent yr or so.

Comet Lake desktop processors vary from $42 for low-end Celeron chips as much as the ten-core i9-10900K for a heftier $488. In the meantime, the high-end Core i9-10980HK for laptops can set you again $583 earlier than you even configure the moveable PC. Intel’s Celeron 5205U laptop computer chip has a recommended worth of $107.

Ice Lake’s smaller portfolio is a bit much less dramatic in pricing, with chips reaching simply above $400. Among the chip pricing isn’t presently out there to the general public; it’s reserved for producers.

Structure

In lots of circumstances, laptops with Comet Lake and Ice Lake compete immediately with each other for consumer curiosity and {dollars}. However they’ve distinctly totally different applied sciences powering them, most notably on the subject of their underlying architectures.

Ice Lake is Intel’s first industrial, 10nm line of processors — the earlier Cannon Lake by no means went mainstream. That’s the primary die shrink that Intel has efficiently accomplished in nearly 5 years, and it’s an enormous one.

The Sunny Cove structure that powers Ice Lake CPUs opens up quite a lot of new directions that may considerably speed up legacy code by encouraging parallel operation. It additionally lowered efficient entry latencies and enhanced the cache over older core designs. Mixed with the shrink to the improved model of Intel’s 10nm course of node, that ends in an enormous improve in single-threaded and multi-threaded efficiency for Ice Lake cellular CPUs over eighth-generation Whiskey Lake chips.

Ice Lake additionally launched Intel’s Eleventh-gen Iris Plus graphics, which supply a major uptick in 3D efficiency over ninth-gen predecessors just like the UHD 620 graphics core. It additionally helps sooner reminiscence than earlier architectures as much as 3,733MHz with out overclocking.

Though you’ll be able to nonetheless discover laptops with Ice Lake chips, most producers have pushed forward to Intel’s Tiger Lake platform. Tiger Lake improves Ice Lake’s design even additional, utilizing the identical 10nm course of whereas bettering the pace of CPU cores. Tiger Lake chips additionally include Intel Xe built-in graphics, and so they’re stable for mild gaming.

Comet Lake is a little bit totally different. It’s constructed on the most recent enhanced model of Intel’s 14nm course of that’s been refreshed annually since Skylake’s 2015 debut. It’s nonetheless sooner than what we’ve seen in Intel’s eighth- and ninth-gen CPUs, nevertheless it doesn’t have the identical, underlying {hardware} revolutions that Ice lake has. It’s extra of an evolution of what’s already out there.

It does, nevertheless, profit from the brand new 400-series chipset, which introduces options like assist for Thunderbolt 3, Wi-Fi 6, Bluetooth 5, and USB 3.2.

Intel provides its Rocket Lake desktop processors now, too, however they present little enchancment over Comet Lake. Rocket Lake is constructed on the identical 14nm course of, and the CPUs within the vary include excessive energy and thermal calls for.

Laptop computer CPUs

Dell 2019 XPS 13 2 in 1 (2019) review
Wealthy Shibley/Digital Traits

Intel led with the cellular market first for its 10nm processors within the type of Ice Lake. The issue: Each Ice Lake and Comet Lake share the identical processor era. Often, you’ll be able to notice the processor generations by the quantity that leads the processor title — for instance, a i9-9900 and i9-10900 are from ninth-gen and Tenth-gen, respectively. As a result of Ice Lake and Comet Lake share a era, you’ll be able to’t use that quantity to inform the distinction between them.

For the present cellular processor market, you wish to have a look at the tip of the processor title as an alternative. Ice Lake and Comet Lake use totally different naming schemes to distinguish every product line. As an example, if the processor has a “G7” or “G5” on the finish, it’s a 10nm Ice Lake chip. If you happen to see an “H,” “U,” or “Y” on the finish, it’s a 14nm Comet Lake chip.

On a deeper stage, the “G5” particularly refers to Ice Lake’s “graphics,” whereas the Comet Lake suffixes vary from high-performance to ultra-low-power. Comet Lake might have a couple of suffix, too, like “HK,” that means the chip is high-performance and unlocked.

With that transient CPU lesson out of the best way, listed here are the entire 14nm Comet Lake cellular CPUs now out there:

Comet Lake H-series

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base
clock
Enhance
clock

(single)
Enhance
clock

(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
Core i9-10980HK 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 2.4GHz 5.3GHz 4.4GHz 1.25GHz 45W
Core i9-10885H 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 2.4GHz 5.3GHz 4.4GHz 1.25GHz 45W
Core i7-10875H 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 2.3GHz 5.1GHz 4.3GHz 1.2GHz 45W
Core i7-10850H 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.7GHz 5.1GHz 4.4GHz 1.15GHz 45W
Core i7-10750H 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.6GHz 5.0GHz 4.3GHz 1.15GHz 45W
Core i5-10400H 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
8MB 2.6GHz 4.6GHz 4.4GHz 1.1GHz 45W
Core i5-10300H 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
8MB 2.5GHz 4.5GHz 4.2GHz 1.05GHz 45w

Comet Lake U-series

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base
clock
Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
Core i7-10810U 6/12 UHD 620
(24)
12MB 1.1GHz 4.9GHz n/a 1.15GHz 15W/25W
Core i7-10710U 6/12 UHD 620
(24)
12MB 1.1GHz 4.7GHz 3.2GHz 1.15GHz 15W/25W
Core i7-10610U 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
8MB 1.8GHz 4.9GHz n/a 1.15GHz 15W/25W
Core i7-10510U 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
8MB 1.8GHz 4.9GHz 3.7GHz 1.15GHz 15W/25W
Core i5-10310U 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
6MB 1.6GHz 4.4GHz n/a 1.15GHz 15W/25W
Core i5-10210U 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
6MB 1.6GHz 4.2GHz 3.8GHz 1.1GHz 15W/25W
Core i3-10110U 2/4 UHD 620
(24)
4MB 2.1GHz 4.1GHz 3.2GHz 1.0GHz 15W/25W
Pentium 6405U 2/4 UHD 610
(12)
2MB 2.4GHz n/a n/a 0.95GHz 12.5W
Celeron 5205U 2/2 UHD 610
(12)
2MB 1.9GHz n/a n/a 0.9GHz 12.5W

Comet Lake Y-series

  Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base clock Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
Core i7-10510Y 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
8MB 1.2GHz 4.5GHz 3.2GHz 1.15GHz 4.5W/7W/9W
Core i5-10310Y 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
6MB 1.1GHz 4.1GHz 2.8GHz 1.05GHz 5.5W/7W/9W
Core i5-10210Y 4/8 UHD 620
(24)
6MB 1.0GHz 4.0GHz 2.7GHz 1.05GHz 4.5W/7W/9W
Core i3-10110Y 2/4 UHD 620
(24)
4MB 1.0GHz 4.0GHz 3.7GHz 1.0GHz 5.5W/7W/9W

A noticeable change over earlier generations of Intel cellular chips are the elevated core counts and clock speeds. However there’s a better distinction between each of Comet Lake’s ranges of cellular chips in comparison immediately with Ice lake.

Listed here are all of the Ice Lake 10nm cellular CPUs

Ice Lake U-series

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base clock Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
Core i7-1068NG7 4/8 Iris Plus
(64)
8MB 2.3GHz 4.1GHz 3.6GHz 1.1GHz 28W
Core i7-1065G7 4/8 Iris Plus
(64)
8MB 1.3GHz 3.9GHz 3.5GHz 1.1GHz 15W/25W
Core i5-1038NG7 4/8 Iris Plus
(64)
6MB 2.0GHz 3.8GHz 3.2GHz 1.05GHz 28W
Core i5-1035G7 4/8 Iris Plus
(64)
6MB 1.2GHz 3.7GHz 3.3GHz 1.05GHz 15W/25W
Core i5-1035G4 4/8 Iris Plus
(48)
6MB 1.1GHz 3.7GHz 3.3GHz 1.05GHz 15W/25W
Core i5-1035G1 4/8 UHD
(32)
6MB 1.0GHz 3.6GHz 3.3GHz 1.05GHz 15W/25W
Core i3-1005G1 2/4 UHD
(32)
4MB 1.2GHz 3.4GHz 3.4GHz 0.9GHz 15W/25W

Ice Lake Y-Sequence

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base
clock
Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase clock
TDP
Core i7-1060G7 4/8 Iris Plus
(64)
8MB 1.0GHz 3.8GHz 3.4GHz 1.1GHz 9W/12W
Core i5-1030G7 4/8 Iris Plus
(64)
6MB 0.8GHz 3.5GHz 3.2GHz 1.05GHz 9W/12W
Core i5-1030G4 4/8 Iris Plus
(48)
6MB 0.7GHz 3.5GHz 3.2GHz 1.05GHz 9W/12W
Core i3-1000G4 2/4 Iris Plus
(48)
4MB 1.1GHz 3.2GHz 3.2GHz 0.9GHz 9W/12W
Core i3-1000G1 2/4 UHD
(32)
4MB 1.1GHz 3.2GHz 3.2GHz 0.9GHz 9W/12W

In relation to core counts and clock pace, Intel’s 14nm Comet Lake chips are a transparent winner right here. The Core i7-1065G7 and Core i7-1068NG7 main the Ice Lake product line each high out at 4 cores and eight threads, whereas the i9s that high the Comet Lake pile clock in at eight cores and 16 threads. A shrink in die dimension might result in higher total efficiency, however that’s not the case right here.

Benchmarks for the i7-1065G7 put it roughly on-par with Comet Lake’s i5-10210U. Stepping again a era, any competing ninth-gen i7 from the H-Sequence can match or beat the quickest Ice Lake chips. This story is additional confirmed with benchmarks for the i9-10980HK, showcasing that its eight cores and 16 threads can maintain up in a cellular setting, even when tuned to blistering clock speeds.

Ice Lake stands out within the graphics division. Though the on-board Iris Plus graphics aren’t going to beat a discrete GPU, they’ve nonetheless put up some first rate efficiency numbers. To be clear, you received’t obtain nice gaming outcomes with Ice Lake or Comet Lake alone. Nevertheless, Ice Lake is significantly better outfitted to deal with mild gaming, and the Iris Plus graphics may even preserve playable body charges in a number of current AAA video games at low settings.

Desktop CPUs

Intel lastly launched its Comet Lake-S desktop CPU household on the finish of April 2020. Thus far, there’s no point out of 10nm Ice Lake desktop chips within the close to future, although 10nm Alder Lake-S is probably going what’s on the horizon for desktops in 2022, falling underneath the Twelfth-gen Intel Core banner.

Right here within the current, we now have an enormous lineup of Comet Lake-S chips at our disposal. As a result of there are such a lot of, we broke the CPU household into teams:

Comet Lake-S Core i9 / Core i7

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base
clock
Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
i9-10900K 10/20 UHD 630
(24)
20MB 3.7GHz 5.3GHz 4.8GHz 1.2GHz 125W
i9-10900KF 10/20 UHD 630
(24)
20MB 3.7GHz 5.3GHz 4.8GHz n/a 125W
i9-10900 10/20 UHD 630
(24)
20MB 2.8GHz 5.2GHz 4.5GHz 1.2GHz 65W
i9-10900F 10/20 UHD 630
(24)
20MB 2.8GHz 5.2GHz 4.5GHz n/a 65W
i9-10900T 10/20 UHD 630
(24)
20MB 1.9GHz 4.6GHz 3.7GHz 1.2GHz 35W
i7-10700K 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 3.8GHz 5.1GHz 4.7GHz 1.2GHz 125W
i7-10700KF 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 3.8GHz 5.1GHz 4.7GHz n/a 125W
i7-10700 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 2.9GHz 4.8GHz 4.6GHz 1.2GHz 65W
i7-10700F 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 2.9GHz 4.8GHz 4.6GHz n/a 65W
i7-10700T 8/16 UHD 630
(24)
16MB 2.0GHz 4.5GHz 3.7GHz 1.2GHz 35W

Comet Lake-S Core i5 / Core i3

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base
clock
Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
i5-10600K 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 4.1GHz 4.8GHz 4.5GHz 1.2GHz 125W
i5-10600KF 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 4.1GHz 4.8GHz 4.5GHz n/a 125W
i5-10600 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 3.3GHz 4.8GHz 4.4GHz 1.2GHz 65W
i5-10600T 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.4GHz 4.0GHz 3.7GHz 1.2GHz 35W
i5-10500 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 3.1GHz 4.5GHz 4.2GHz 1.5GHz 65W
i5-10500T 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.3GHz 3.8GHz 3.5GHz 1.5GHz 35W
i5-10400 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.9GHz 4.3GHz 4.0GHz 1.1GHz 65W
i5-10400F 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.9GHz 4.3GHz 4.0GHz n/a 65W
i5-10400T 6/12 UHD 630
(24)
12MB 2.0GHz 3.6GHz 3.2GHz 1.1GHz 35W
i3-10320 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
8MB 3.8GHz 4.6GHz 4.4GHz 1.5 GHz 65W
i3-10300 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
8MB 3.7GHz 4.4GHz 4.2GHz 1.5 GHz 65W
i3-10300T 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
8MB 3.0GHz 3.9GHz 3.6GHz 1.1 GHz 35W
i3-10100 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
6MB 3.6GHz 4.3GHz 4.1GHz 1.1GHz 65W
i3-10100T 4/8 UHD 630
(24)
6MB 3.0GHz 3.8GHz 3.6GHz 1.1GHz 35W

Comet Lake-S Pentium Gold / Celeron

Cores
/threads
Graphics
(EUs)
Cache Base
clock
Enhance
clock
(single)
Enhance
clock
(all)
Graphics
increase
clock
TDP
Pentium Gold G6600 2/4 UHD 630
(24)
4MB 4.2GHz n/a n/a 1.1GHz 58W
Pentium Gold G6500 2/4 UHD 630
(24)
4MB 4.1GHz n/a n/a 1.1GHz 58W
Pentium Gold G6500T 2/4 UHD 630
(24)
4MB 3.5GHz n/a n/a 1.05GHz 35W
Pentium Gold G6400 2/4 UHD 610
(12)
4MB 4.0GHz n/a n/a 1.05GHz 58W
Pentium Gold G6400T 2/4 UHD 610
(12)
4MB 3.4GHz n/a n/a 1.05GHz 35W
Celeron G5920 2/2 UHD 610
(12)
2MB 3.5GHz n/a n/a 1.05GHz 58W
Celeron G5900 2/2 UHD 610
(12)
2MB 3.4GHz n/a n/a 1.05GHz 58W
Celeron G5900T 2/2 UHD 610
(12)
2MB 3.2GHz n/a n/a 1.0GHz 35W

Comet Lake chips embrace the flexibility to toggle hyperthreading on and off on a core-by-core foundation. The concept is to disable hyperthreading on inactive cores, which interprets to decrease warmth and decrease energy attracts. Toggling additionally permits all cores presently utilizing hyperthreading to stay in turbo mode for extra prolonged durations. Hyperthreading controls are supplied by means of the BIOS, not within the working system.

Current benchmarks present Intel’s flagship ten-core chip, the i9-10900K, going face to face with AMD’s Ryzen 9 3900X 12-core CPU within the 3DMark Fireplace Strike Physics take a look at. It pulled only a few factors forward of AMD’s chip when overclocked at 5.1GHz. What’s notable is that it outperforms Intel’s earlier champion, the Core i9-9900K, whereas promoting at an analogous recommended worth.

Any hopes for Ice Lake on desktop are all however lifeless. Intel is difficult at work on Alder Lake, which ought to mark the corporate’s first desktop die shrink in a few years.

In relation to Comet Lake versus Ice Lake, the reality is that every is a good possibility in sure conditions. Comet Lake continues to be nice on desktop, despite the fact that Intel Rocket Lake is already right here. For cellular, we suggest going for a Tiger Lake laptop computer over an Ice Lake one. Tiger Lake options one of the best chip specs for laptops proper now and far improved graphics.

There is no such thing as a clear winner between these two chips, even for those who occur to find choices that offer you a alternative between the 2. Each have their respective advantages. To make sure you get one of the best chip in your wants, determine how vital it’s that your laptop multitasks with out lag. For instance, if you’re gaming or modifying movies and photographs, you don’t need different duties to lag. You additionally don’t wish to drain your laptop computer’s energy shortly. Keep in mind that for those who don’t ceaselessly use the battery, you received’t want to fret in regards to the battery lifespan.

Editors’ Suggestions








Supply hyperlink

Leave a reply